33 From Scratch Pumpkin Recipes You Need to Make This Fall


All of the best from scratch, pumpkin recipes, everything from pumpkin pie to breads, cookies and brownies, granola, and more!

October is here and fall is upon us. What better way to celebrate the seasonal change then by embracing all things pumpkin!

We’ve rounded up our favorite from scratch pumpkin recipes that you need to make this fall. No funky ingredients, just real, homemade food.

Some are healthier than others. Many are from our favorite homesteading bloggers, others from some of the best food bloggers. All of them are delicious and homemade and will be perfect to make this fall. Bookmark your favorites.

We threw in a couple savory pumpkin dishes for good measure, but who are we kidding, fall is the time for all things sweet.

Click the photos or the captions below the photos to head over to the recipes.

Related: Pumpkin Spice Streusel Muffins

Happy pumpkin season!

PSA: Did you know we have a FREE ebook on seven ways to be more efficient and effective with your homemaking? Click HERE to subscribe to our newsletter and you’ll get the ebook sent to you right away.

From scratch pumpkin pie sweetened only with honey! It doesn’t get more from scratch or fall than that. Head over and get the recipe and make it for your next fall gathering.

I’ve made this several times since the weather has gotten cooler, and each time it does not disappoint. Its the perfect, caffeine-free drink to warm up to in the evenings.

If you love a good cheesecake you’ll love this pumpkin swirl cheesecake by Reformation Acres. The ginger candied pecans are the cherry on top.

Pumpkin cookies you can feel better about eating whenever you want, which will be all the time. Made with whole wheat flour and oats, they’ll be your go-to snack this fall.

What are all these recipes if you don’t have your own from scratch pumpkin pie spice. Whip up a batch of this and you’ll be golden for all of these delicious pumpkin recipes.

The recipe says ‘from grandma’s kitchen’… need we say more? Grandma’s know best in from scratch cooking and this pumpkin roll recipe will not disappoint.

Sugar cookies are a classic, and these old-fashioned, pumpkin sugar cookies give the traditional treat a perfect fall twist. Make them for your next bake sale!

Maple flavors are sometimes overlooked, but they scream fall and homemade to me. Make this honey maple pumpkin bread for your family tonight.

Light and fluffy and full of pumpkin flavor, these pumpkin cream puffs are easier to make then you might think. The filling includes heavy cream and real maple syrup. We’re sold.

I love a good milkshake, and this pumpkin pie milkshake by Jill over at The Prairie Homestead has my mouth watering!

Another warm drink to cozy up with on crisp fall days. Though not as healthy for you (i.e. 4 cups of heavy whipping cream!) We think our waistlines will understand ;)

Warm oatmeal is one of the best ways to start your day, and this pumpkin pie oatmeal by Dr. Axe will make it that much better.

This bread is a lot like a banana bread, quick and easy to make, you could have it ready for an after dinner snack this evening if you wanted.

Granola bars are the perfect snack in the fall and for back-to-school. Ditch the store-bought ones and opt for these from scratch granola bars by Simple Farmstead Cooking, made with pumpkin and white chocolate.

Granola is so versatile, you can have it over top your homemade yogurt, with fresh milk, on top of your oatmeal, or by the handful as a snack. This pumpkin spice granola will be your go-to fall recipe.

Made with raw milk, einkorn flour, and Victoria’s homemade vanilla, these pumpkin muffins are the perfect snack anytime of day.

She shows you everything from how to roast your pumpkin to how to make the homemade, honey mustard dressing that’s drizzled on top. From scratch and delicious!

This Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream is made with bourbon, but you can just as easily omit the bourbon and opt for real vanilla instead. What a fun and unique fall dessert!

Scones are the perfect fall treat, especially when paired with a warm drink. These scones are made with coconut sugar and whole wheat pastry flour (so a bit better for you) and are topped with a maple, cream cheese glaze. YUM.

We can’t have a list of pumpkin recipes without including a tried and true pumpkin spice latte recipe! This latte is made with coconut milk and pure maple syrup, and is sure to suffice all of your fall latte dreams.

Again, made with coconut milk and paleo flour (though you can likely substitute your favorite milk, perhaps raw milk, as well as a different flour), these pumpkin, blueberry muffins look like the perfect, fall breakfast.

From SCRATCH. The pictures of Laurie making this delicious soup should be enough to have you click over. She even shows you how to roast the tomatoes


This pumpkin pudding cake by Laurie over at Simply Scratch looks to die for. If done right, the edges should caramelize and the center should be warm and gooey.

Pumpkin, cheesecake, and brownies, all in one! These pumpkin brownies would be perfect for a potluck or a fall bake sale.

A good, from scratch recipe for pumpkin, chocolate chip cookies is a perfect to have in your fall baking repertoire. These cookies from Tastes Better From Scratch will do the trick!

Made with almond flour and coconut sugar, these grain-free pumpkin spice muffins will be your go-to healthy snack.

Whoopie pies have been one of my favorite cookies since I was a young girl, so you bet I was excited to find these fall inspired, pumpkin whoopie pies by Holistic Squid. Excuse me while I make seven batches.

Pumpkin bars you can feel better about. Whip up a batch of these and snack on them as much as you like!

Made with whole wheat flour and stuffed with a sweet pumpkin filling, these cookies would be perfect as a quick breakfast with a hot cup of Jo.

A healthier pumpkin muffin recipe using leftover sourdough starter, will help you to feel better about feeding these goodies to your family. Head over and get the recipe!

These pumpkin snack bars are easy to whip up, with ingredients you most likely have on hand, and would be a perfect lunch or after school snack for the kiddos. Or for you;)

Have you ever heard of pumpkin soft pretzels before? Neither had I, but man oh man I can’t wait to try this recipe, it seems perfect for a fall gathering or game day food.

Move aside Starbucks, we have a from scratch recipe for pumpkin cheesecake muffins that we think have yours beat. I cant wait to try these to have with my homemade pumpkin spice latte. All the yum, none of the artificial junk.

We hope you find something you love to make for you and your family this fall. Cooking from scratch can be so rewarding and so delicious. So, the next time you go to buy a pumpkin cheesecake muffin from Starbucks, or a pre-made pie at the grocery store, think again. Head back over here and get the recipe for your favorite dish, made from scratch. Happy FALL!

Pin it for later!

Pumpkin Recipes.png

Follow us on Pinterest for more fall recipe inspiration and all things COUNTRY living!

Thanks for stopping by!

Check out our recent posts!